"For a first time and given your general personality, I don't think you're being a dork at all." Hartley grinned and kissed Cisco's ass where he'd bitten it, then finally put his hand between his legs. "This is going to be cold."

He had tried to warm his fingers up a little, but that would still feel cold to Cisco nonetheless. He was gentle as he just teased around the entrance, watching carefully for any reaction from Cisco. "It's more weird than hot at first. That's normal. Just wait."

He finally moved one finger inside him, slowly, but insistently and when he found his prostate, he brushed against it.

"How's that?"