No, Hartley wasn't surprised at the impromptu puppet show. He had known James for too long to even be slightly taken aback by something like that. However, it was a clear sign that something serious was going on, because contrary to what one might think, usually when James brought out the puppets, the issue was complicated and emotional.

He finally reached out to grab James' wrists, making sure to catch his eyes. "Talk to me, James. Giacomo."